Special Orders:


Please call/email ahead – if we can have it for you, we will!

Please note - you can always reserve pies for pickup later in the day (except certain holidays) based on what is on hand at the time – just give us a call!

Our Special Orders Menu [download here] includes pies that are available to order but not necessarily maintained on hand at store at all times. We can also customize most pies with dough symbols, names, dates, etc. Pricing is based on length and complexity of customization.

We gladly accept special orders, including customization, with 2 to 7 business days advanced notice, depending on exact products/quantities and subject to ingredient availability. We make everything by hand, and in small batches, so your pies are specifically made for you!

You can contact us by phone 206.938.0680 to make a special order inquiry or email Kimmy at kimmy@shooflypiecompany.com. Please include in your email your name, phone number, which pies you would like, pickup date and approximate time. We will email you back to confirm the order and take payment.

Please do not assume we have received your order until you receive an email confirmation.


We work with you to ensure you have the perfect, unique dessert for your guests on your wedding day, bridal shower or engagement party. Please call or email to make an appointment with a baker for a complimentary tasting and to discuss your plans for your special day! Delivery options are available.


Looking for an alternative to a whole pie, or have a group of people with varying tastes? Our new cupPies and cutiePies are the perfect size for office meetings, book club night, birthday parties, twin peaks night, Oscar parties, movie night... and basically just about any time you can think of! Buy one for yourself or a whole dozen to share with others. Throw a candle on top for the bday boy or girl - check out the jar by the counter for some unique candles.

Our pies are pretty, well, pretty just the way they are J, but we can also customize for your occasion - just call or email us ahead to discuss! Delivery options are available.


Please note that for the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays, we feature limited menus and set order-by deadlines. Please see our menu page for pies offered. We also make a limited amount of extra pie for day-of purchase on a first-come-first-served basis. Please call for details and to place your order (please, no email orders for holiday pies).